Dropshipping Vs Amazon FBA: Which Is Better?

Today, we’re going to talk about the good and bad sides of Amazon FBA and dropshipping.

Selling products online has been a big deal for a while now. Lots of folks have made a ton of money doing it from their kitchen tables.

But it wasn’t always easy. Imagine standing in a long line at the post office, trying to ship out packages, while everyone behind you gets more and more annoyed. Yikes!

Then, dropshipping and Amazon FBA showed up and changed the game. Suddenly, you didn’t have to deal with all that shipping hassle.

These days, if you’re starting a new online business, you’re probably thinking about either dropshipping or Amazon FBA. But which one’s better for you?

Well, it depends. You’ve got to ask yourself some important questions to figure out which way to go. We’ll help you out with that.

So, if you’re thinking about starting an online store or growing your current one, stick around. We’ll help you decide between Amazon FBA and dropshipping.

What is Dropshipping?

Dropshipping is a way for online stores to handle orders without dealing with the hassle of stocking and shipping products themselves. Instead, they partner with a third-party supplier who handles all that stuff.

Here’s how it works: You set up your online shop and showcase products. When someone buys something from your store, you forward the order details to the supplier. Then, the supplier ships the product directly to the customer.

It’s a popular option because it saves you the trouble of managing inventory and shipping, which can be a big headache. However, it’s important to note that relying on dropshipping can sometimes lead to issues with customer satisfaction, as you’re not directly in control of the product quality or shipping speed.

But don’t worry! There are alternatives to dropshipping that might suit your business better. We’ll dive into those too.

What is Amazon FBA?

Amazon FBA, or Fulfillment by Amazon, is a service provided by Amazon for sellers who want to streamline their order fulfillment process.

Here’s how it works: Sellers send their products to Amazon’s warehouses, and Amazon takes care of storing, packing, and shipping the products when orders come in. This includes handling returns and refunds too.

Basically, once you’ve sent your stuff to Amazon, they handle the rest. All you have to do is manage your sales and make sure Amazon has enough of your products in stock.

It’s a popular choice for sellers because it takes a lot of the logistical headaches out of running an online store. Plus, it gives your products the advantage of being eligible for Amazon Prime shipping, which many customers love.

The Pros and Cons of Dropshipping vs Amazon FBA

Dropshipping Pros

  1. Lower Overhead Costs: You save money because you don’t need to store or ship products. This means less spending on things like storage spaces and shipping fees.

  2. Minimal Starting Costs: If you’re starting a business with little money, dropshipping is great because you don’t need to buy facilities or resources for handling orders.

  3. Less Risk: Since you’re not buying inventory upfront, you’re less likely to lose money if products don’t sell or if you order too much.

  4. Sell Everywhere: You can use dropshipping to sell products on your own website, on platforms like Amazon, or even through social media.

  5. Work from Anywhere: With dropshipping, you can fulfill orders from anywhere, giving you the flexibility to work from wherever you want.

  6. Easy to Scale: You can handle more orders without needing to stock more products, which makes growing your business easier.

  7. Lots of Products: You can sell a wide range of items without having to buy them first, so you have more options and can potentially make more money.

  8. Try Different Products: You can experiment with different products to see what sells best without worrying about wasting money on inventory.

Dropshipping Cons

  1. Tough Competition: Because it’s easy and cheap to start dropshipping, there are lots of people doing it, making the market crowded and competitive.

  2. Product Quality Concerns: Since you’re not directly involved in shipping products, it’s harder to make sure they’re good quality, which could lead to unhappy customers.

  3. Branding Challenges: It’s hard to stand out when you’re selling products that others are also selling, making it tricky to build a unique brand identity.

  4. Slim Profit Margins: Because products might not be unique, you might end up in price wars with other sellers, cutting into your profits.

  5. Uncertain Fulfillment Times: You don’t control how orders are processed and shipped, so there might be delays or issues that affect customer satisfaction.

  6. Inventory Problems: You might not always know if a product is in stock, leading to situations where customers order something only to find out it’s unavailable, which can harm your reputation.

  7. Limited Special Offers: Since you don’t handle shipping, you might not be able to offer certain deals like free shipping or bundled products.

  8. Supplier Errors: Sometimes, the companies you work with to dropship products might make mistakes, like sending the wrong item or leaving things out of the package.

  9. Complicated Customer Service: Even though you’re not shipping products yourself, you’re still responsible for making sure customers are happy, which can be tough if there are problems with orders.

Amazon FBA Pros

  1. Logistics Support and Scalability: Amazon handles packing, shipping, and customer service, making it easier to scale your business without worrying about logistics.

  2. Amazon Prime Benefits: Products in FBA automatically qualify for Prime shipping, enhancing customer satisfaction without additional fees.

  3. Winning the Buy Box: FBA sellers get access to the Buy Box, increasing visibility and boosting sales potential.

  4. Shipping Discounts: Working with Amazon means lower shipping costs, saving you money compared to managing shipping yourself.

  5. 24/7 Customer Support: Amazon provides round-the-clock customer service for FBA sellers, simplifying support management.

  6. More Storage Space: FBA offers unlimited storage in Amazon’s warehouses, eliminating worries about inventory space.

  7. Multi-Channel Fulfillment: You can use FBA to sell on various platforms beyond Amazon, expanding your reach while still utilizing Amazon’s fulfillment services.

Amazon FBA Cons

  1. Costly: While convenient, FBA comes with fees that may not fit everyone’s budget, especially for low-cost items.

  2. Inventory Management: You need to meet Amazon’s requirements for product preparation, packaging, labeling, and shipping, which requires ongoing attention to inventory details.

  3. Limited Branding: Your branding opportunities are limited because Amazon handles packaging and shipping, often with their logo prominently displayed.

  4. Commingling: Amazon combines products from different sellers, which can lead to your products being mixed with lower-quality items from other sellers.

  5. More Returns: Some sellers experience increased returns due to Amazon’s open return policy, although Amazon now handles return processing directly.

Difference Between Amazon FBA and Dropshipping

Amazon FBA and dropshipping are pretty similar, but they have some key differences.

1. Inventory Ownership

With Amazon FBA, you own the inventory. You buy products in bulk and send them to Amazon’s fulfillment centers.

Dropshipping doesn’t require you to own inventory upfront. You only buy products from suppliers after you receive orders from customers.

2. Order Fulfillment Process

For FBA, Amazon handles the entire fulfillment process, from storing inventory to shipping orders to customers.

In dropshipping, your supplier ships orders directly to your customers after you place an order with them.

3. Returns Handling

In FBA, Amazon deals with returns.

In dropshipping, you manage returns yourself, as the seller, since you’re using the FBM (Fulfilled by Merchant) method on Amazon. Returns can’t be sent back to the supplier.

4. Customer Service

Amazon takes care of customer service and returns for FBA orders.

With dropshipping, you’re responsible for handling customer inquiries and returns.

Which is Right for Your Business: Amazon FBA vs Dropshipping

Choosing between Amazon FBA and Dropshipping for your business comes with its own set of upsides and downsides. 

Dropshipping is great for those starting out with little capital. It’s low-risk since you don’t need to invest upfront in inventory. Platforms like Shopify make it easy to set up shop and start selling. So, if you’re cautious and want to dip your toes into ecommerce without big investments, dropshipping could be your go-to.

On the other hand, if you’ve got some cash to spare and you’re willing to take a bit of a gamble, Amazon FBA might be more your style. With FBA, you leverage Amazon’s huge customer base, which can mean big returns. Plus, with Amazon handling shipping and customer service, you can focus more on marketing your products. However, it does require a decent initial investment. So, I’d say it’s best for those already in the ecommerce game who want to scale up. 

But remember, neither option gives you full control. With FBA, you’re bound by Amazon’s rules, and with dropshipping, profit margins can be razor-thin. So, weigh your options carefully based on your business goals and financial situation.

If you need more guidance, sign up for my online business coaching

Interested in receiving one-on-one mentorship for building an online business? Join my online business coaching program.

Leave a Comment

1-on-1 Online Business Coaching Program